< All Blog Posts

Anaerobic Digestion vs. Composting: Choosing the Best Organic Waste Management Method

8 min read

Two commonly used methods for managing organic waste are anaerobic digestion and composting. Both effectively divert organic waste from landfills, reducing methane emissions and alleviating pressure on waste management infrastructure. They are environmentally friendly options suitable for both small-scale and community-based applications. While both techniques have the common goal of converting organic matter into useful products, they differ in their processes and applications. In this blog post, we will explore the differences between anaerobic digestion and composting and discuss the circumstances in which each method is most suitable.

The Synergy: How Anaerobic Digestion Complements Composting

While both anaerobic digestion and composting share a purpose of minimizing the environmental impact of organic waste and maximizing the value from the materials, they do so in distinct ways that complement one another. Composting requires space and time for the natural decomposition of highly fibrous materials leading to effectiveness in smaller-scale applications. In contrast, the quick operational readiness and compact design of anaerobic digesters make them suitable to process a wide range of organic waste into biogas and biofertilizer in medium-to-large scale contexts. When deciding between these methods or using them together, consider factors like waste type and volume, available resources, and the desired end products. Learn more about how anaerobic digestion complements composting.

Understanding Anaerobic Digestion

Anaerobic digestion is a biological process that decomposes organic materials in the absence of oxygen. This technique utilizes microorganisms to break down organic matter into biogas, a mixture of methane and carbon dioxide, as well as a nutrient-rich byproduct known as digestate. Anaerobic digestion typically takes place in sealed containers called digesters, where controlled conditions optimize the decomposition process.

The Benefits of Anaerobic Digestion:

1. Biogas Production: The primary advantage of anaerobic digestion is the generation of biogas, a renewable energy source that can be used for heating, electricity generation, or even as a vehicle fuel. Biogas production helps reduce dependence on fossil fuels and mitigates greenhouse gas emissions. 

2. Waste Management of Varied Organic Waste Feedstocks: Anaerobic digestion can effectively process a wide range of organic waste, including food waste, agricultural residues, and sewage sludge, that can typically be challenging to deal with because of odor and other concerns. Because anaerobic digestion occurs in a sealed environment, odors are easier to control and the potential for undesirable runoff is eliminated.

3. Digestate as Fertilizer: The digestate produced as a byproduct of anaerobic digestion is rich in nutrients, making it an excellent biofertilizer. It can be used to enhance soil fertility, improve crop yields, and close nutrient loops in agriculture. These nutrient loops ensure that all of the valuable nutrients within agriculture are continually utilized as shown below. 

When to Choose Anaerobic Digestion:

Anaerobic digestion is ideal when:

1. Energy Generation is a Priority: If the primary goal is to produce renewable energy, anaerobic digestion is a suitable choice. It is particularly beneficial for facilities with a consistent supply of organic waste, such as large-scale farms, universities, food processors, waste haulers and more. 

2. Managing Organic Waste of  25 - 4500 tons/year: Anaerobic digestion is well-suited for managing medium-large volumes of organic waste generated by companies and municipalities. It provides an efficient way to reduce waste, capture energy, and minimize environmental impact. 

3. Space is constrained: Smaller-scale solutions like Chomp’s are built for communities of 500-100K people in urban or rural settings since they are compact and able to be delivered and operational within six months.

4. Odor and other nuisances are a priority to control: Because Chomp’s solutions are designed to be self-contained and operated entirely on-site, odor can be more easily controlled. In addition, noise, traffic, and pollution are eliminated.

How to get started with anaerobic digestion:

  1. Get your data: Determine your amount and type of organic waste that will be fed to the digester. For example, 750 tons of food waste from a cafeteria per year.
  1. Look for solutions: 
  • Small Scale Providers (550~ Gallons/year): Household-level providers such as Homebiogas are best suited for individual homes.
  • Medium Scale Providers (25-4500 tons/year): This scale supports communities of 500-100K people including universities, food processors, waste haulers, utilities and more. Chomp is ideal for these urban settings as our systems are odor-free, compact, and can be delivered and operational within six months.
  • Large Scale Industrial Providers (5000+ tons/year): Best served by solutions such as Bioenergy Devco.
  1. Obtain Funding & Project Kick-off:

Exploring Composting

Composting is a natural process that decomposes organic materials in the presence of oxygen. It relies on the activity of aerobic microorganisms, such as bacteria, fungi, and insects, to break down organic matter. Composting can occur in various settings, including backyard compost piles, large-scale composting facilities, or controlled composting systems.

The Advantages of Composting:

1. Soil Improvement: Compost acts as a valuable soil conditioner, enriching soil structure, enhancing moisture retention, and promoting the growth of beneficial microorganisms. It provides essential nutrients to plants, reduces the need for synthetic fertilizers, and improves overall soil health.

2. Green waste management: Composting is especially well suited for high carbon feedstocks typically found in curbside yard waste collection and drop-off programs. These feedstocks benefit from a longer composting residence time.

3. Versatile Applications: Finished compost has diverse applications, including landscaping, horticulture, urban farming, and agriculture. It can be used in gardens, parks, farms, and even as a component in growing media for nurseries and greenhouses.

When to Choose Composting:

Composting is a preferable choice when:

1.Managing Organic Waste at a Small Scale: For individual households, community gardens, or small-scale agricultural operations, composting is an ideal solution.

2. Soil Enrichment and Regeneration is a priority: If the main objective is to enhance soil quality, improve plant growth, and support sustainable agriculture, composting is an excellent choice. It helps restore depleted soils, mitigate erosion, and promote biodiversity.

3. Space is not a constraint: To reach full composting maturity, space and time are required. When these resources are readily available, composting may be a good option.

4. Your organic waste is highly fibrous. If you have more green waste, such as leaves, landscaping waste, weeds, etc., it is well-suited for decomposing these materials.

In the realm of organic waste management, both anaerobic digestion and composting offer valuable solutions for minimizing environmental impact and maximizing resource utilization. Anaerobic digestion excels in medium-to-large scale applications where energy generation is a priority, while composting shines in smaller-scale contexts, focusing on soil improvement and organic waste diversion. The choice between the two methods or to use multiple solutions simultaneously ultimately depends on factors such as waste volume, available resources, and the desired end products. By adopting these techniques appropriately, we can move closer to a more sustainable future while minimizing waste and maximizing the value of organic materials.

Get the guide

Anaerobic Digestion VS Composting Guide